no offense but even if cook didn't get much pretty comments from simon in his two last performances i still want him to win! for me COOK is the winner! Who are u going to vote for?

I think David A nailed all 3 songs. I prefer David Cook though. I would rather see David Cook loose so he isn't stuck with the contract from Idol. He can do better signing with a different label. Either way, each will end up with a career and contract.

i want to vote for DAVID A cause he is so sweet and he nailed thoose 3 songs

No one should listen to Simon. Everyone knows that he's been wrong many times before. He's got something against Cook from the beginning (remember he told him that he was conceided?) so scew Simon.
Anyone who listen to Simon is an idiot.
David cook will sell so much more records than baby Archuleta.
David Cook all the way*********************

Oh my God, I had to turn the TV off last night because I couldn't stand to see or hear David A. sing again. He always sounds the same and he such a total goof ball when Ryan is trying to talk to him. I can't imagine him in concert. I love David Cook and he will have an amazing career that I am sure of.

DA did amazing. but DAVID COOK IS THE BEST CONTESTANT EVER.
i hope he wins!!!

I actually really like them both. I disagreed with Simon in the first round, I liked David Cooks song and performance better. I agreed with the next two though, I liked David Archuleta's songs and performances better. They both are great singers. They have different styles. I like David A's voice and genuineness. I like what David C does with songs like Billy Jean and Hello. They both are better than each other at different things. I think David A will win. This is the first year I haven't cared who does. I think they both are awesome and both will have dream careers. I think both will be pleased with how far they've come whether or not they win.

I think that David A is JUST a good singer.

He doesn't have any presence on stage, he just stands there.

David C, doesn't have his range, but the last time I checked it's not about who can sing higher.

It's who we are actually entertained by.

I think David A could have a long career for Disney doing voiceovers and soundtracks, well, at least until he goes through puberty. Then I'm not sure what he will do because no one over 13 is going to buy his records. And no one will remember his name in 1 year when the next idol is crowned.

David C has the look, the sound and the originality that Idol has never had, so I doubt he will win because he can't be packaged to teens as easily as David A.

But that's probably better because it will leave David C open to get a contract from a rock label that will be able the handle him.

More power to both of them.

However I won't be buying a David A album, but I would fork over $20 to see what David C can do with his own band.

I'm rooting for David Cook! I mean, he did have a point when he said there was no point in singing a song again. David Archuleta, although I do like him, is a little too predictable. I knew exactly what he was going to sing for Round 3 and I just don't think he can sing anything else besides slow songs. David Cook has much more variety.